Custom Dining Chairs Made by Amish

Your home is your canvas, and your decor is your paintbrush. Every detail is yours to control, from the color of the walls to the material of the rugs to the light fixtures overhead. With that in mind, why settle for mass-produced dining chairs when you can choose pieces crafted to reflect your style?
Countryside Amish Furniture offers hundreds of dining chair designs that patrons can customize to meet their creative vision. Curious to see options for your living room? Check out custom upholstered arm chairs.
Ways We Enable You to Customize Your Dining Chair
Customizations Available to All Dining Chairs
- Wood species - Countryside Amish Furniture proudly offers an array of North American hardwoods, each bringing its own subtle character to the dining chair design. While oak, white oak, cherry, and brown maple are popular choices, we also offer hickory, maple, walnut, and elm, among others. On occasion, some of our pieces’ pages will only list one species—most common to rough sawn maple or reclaimed barnwood. However, because each dining chair is customizable, we may be able to accommodate requests for the designs to be made in solid wood species not reflected on the page.
- Wood stains - Each choice of wood is supplemented by dozens of color options ranging from subtle to bold. Not only do you get to select the finish our Amish woodworkers apply, but you can opt to include more than one! We gladly accommodate custom requests for dining chairs with dual stains, creating a look that is both refreshingly modern and entirely unique.
Customizations Available to Many of Our Dining Chairs
- The option to add or exclude arms - Side arms can provide extra comfort, while the absence of arms reduces the width of each chair, allowing you to fit more around the table. Choose the option that best suits your needs—perhaps even a combination of both—and we’ll customize the dining room set just for you.
- The choice of upholstery: leather or fabric - Many of our customizable dining chairs feature upholstered options, including seat cushions, backrests, or full-body coverage in your chosen material. For such chairs, you often have the choice between two different types of textiles—fabric or full grain leather. Each comes in dozens of colors, ranging from subdued Bourbon Brown to bold Juniper green.
- Whether to include a seat cushion - Many of our chairs are offered with or without seat cushions. As mentioned above, any cushion will be available in your preferred fabric or leather.
- Style of nail head trim - Your hand-selected nail trim will highlight the dining chair’s upholstery, adding a distinctive custom touch. Choose wisely, as it’s the finishing detail that makes all the difference! While we offer a full assortment, popular options include Antique Pearl, Pewter, Old Brass, Old Gold Z, and Dull Black.
Can you make specialty customization requests: At Countryside Amish Furniture, we take pride in going the extra mile to bring our customers’ visions to life. Often, this involves offering customizations beyond what’s listed on our product pages, such as two-tone staining. However, because our dining chairs are meticulously crafted for optimal ergonomics, we may advise against customizations that alter the proportions or compromise the integrity of the design. We invite you to chat with a member of our team via Live Chat to discuss any customizations you have in mind for your dining chairs.
To browse the many types of dining chairs you can customize, browse:
Classic wooden dining chairs | Farmhouse dining chairs | Bar and kitchen island chairs | Bow back chairs | Upholstered dining chairs
Popular Upholstered Dining Chairs You Can Customize
The Beaman Upholstered Dining Chair shows a simple design that is infinitely versatile. While it sports a fabric-stain combo that boldly contrasts for a modern aesthetic, you can customize the dining chair’s coloring for a more classic, gentle look. Better still, like many chairs we build for customers, this piece can come with or without arms.
Key Features
- Solid hardwood construction
- Side or arm chair available
- Fabric or leather upholstery
- Custom hardwood & finish
- Amish handmade in the USA
Price: $513
There’s a lot to love about this chair, shown here with brown maple legs and old gold Z nailhead trim. But the beauty of the Alice Upholstered Accent Chair is that it’s entirely yours to customize. Opt for naturally stained walnut or quartersawn white oak with a light finish. Swap the nailhead trim for antique pearl or pewter. Choose from a range of fabrics or go for leather in the color of your choice. However you style it, this chair can be customized to fit your dining room like a glove.
Key Features
- Amish made in the USA
- Solid hardwood frame
- Mortise & tenon joinery
- Leather or fabric upholstery
- Optional nail head trim
- Reinforced attachments
- Custom hardwood & finish
Price: $830
The more you look, the more you’ll appreciate the thoughtful details that set this customizable dining chair apart. Its front legs showcase a French Country-inspired turned design, while the back legs have a sleek, contemporary flare. The circular back adds an unexpected touch, breaking away from traditional shapes. Opt for arms, and you’ll get elegantly curved swoops that strike the perfect balance between modern and timeless femininity. However you choose to customize it, this chair exudes effortless sophistication.
Key Features
- Solid hardwood construction
- Fabric or leather upholstery
- Side or arm chair available
- Mortise & tenon joinery
- Amish handmade in the USA
- Catalyzed conversion varnish
Price: $1305
While undeniably modern, this customizable dining chair is designed for lasting comfort and ergonomic support that never goes out of style. Whether you choose fabric or leather upholstery, each piece is meticulously hand-built to meet the highest Amish woodworking standards—delivering a perfect balance of beauty and durability.
Key Features
- Solid hardwood construction
- Fabric or leather upholstery
- Reinforced attachments
- Mortise & tenon joinery
- Catalyzed conversion varnish
- Amish handmade in the USA
Price: $863
Make the already-unique Amboy Dining Chair entirely your own with customizations from Countryside Amish Furniture. Inspired by Scandinavian simplicity, this barrel-backed design can be upholstered in fabric or leather and finished in the wood and stain that best suits your vision. Best of all, every element of this chair is executed using timeless Amish woodworking techniques to ensure your seating will endure decades of daily use. If you like this particular style of chair, check out Low Back Dining Chairs Made From Solid Wood for more inspiration.
Key Features
- Solid hardwood construction
- Fabric or leather upholstery
- Mortise & tenon joinery
- Amish handmade in the USA
- Catalyzed conversion varnish
Price: $1255
The Camak Upholstered Chair showcases a refined Mid-Century-inspired design with sleek, tapered legs. Despite its airy appearance, expert Amish craftsmanship and solid hardwood construction ensure lasting durability. As with all our chairs, the Camak is built to order, giving you the freedom to customize the wood species, stain, and upholstery to suit your style.
Key Features
- Solid hardwood construction
- Amish handcrafted to order
- Leather or fabric upholstery
- Floor glides under feet
- Reinforced attachments
- Catalyzed conversion varnish
- Custom hardwood & finish
Price: $547
The McAllen Upholstered Chair blends Mid-Century influences with a versatility that can lean modern, depending on your choices. Crafted in oak, brown maple, or cherry, it can be finished in a wide range of stains, from deep and dramatic to light and natural. Upholstery options include both leather and fabric, allowing you to customize a dining chair that perfectly complements your space.
Key Features
- Solid hardwood construction
- Fabric or leather upholstery
- Reinforced corner blocks
- Catalyzed conversion varnish
- Amish handmade in the USA
- Custom hardwood & finish
Price: $823
Customizable Upholstered Dining Chairs
Popular Non-Upholstered Dining Chairs You Can Customize
While the Sweetfield Spindle Kitchen Chair would look right at home in Colonial times, you can customize the choice of stain or paint for a more modern vibe. For a particularly unique spin on this classic design, you can even make a special request for two different colors! Our point is that this bow back chair can accommodate almost any style of dining room when completed with the right stain.
Key Features
- Solid wood construction
- Oak or Brown Maple
- Side or arm chair available
- Reinforced attachments
- Handmade in the USA
- Catalyzed conversion varnish
Price: $275
The Amish-made Dubberly Dining Chair offers many of the same customizations as many of the other seating in this article—multiple wood species options, a full range of stains, and the choice to include a seat cushion. However, it goes one step further to allow customers to select whether the metal back pattern should be executed in silver, gold, or tex black metal. With so many potential aesthetic combinations, the resulting chair will truly feel one-of-a-kind to your home.
Key Features
- Solid hardwood construction
- Metal color back options
- Wooden or upholstered seat
- Amish handmade in the USA
- Custom hardwood & finish
- Catalyzed conversion varnish
Price: $442
Whether you customize this dining chair to sport white, black, or natural coloring, the Austell Farmhouse Chair is sure to provide style and comfort alike. Specific details include the scooped seat, turned legs, and the classic Windsor back design. While this customizable chair can pair well with a full range of tables, it can be bought as part of the coordinating Austell Dining Set, complete with a modern farmhouse table and sideboard.
Key Features
- Solid hardwood construction
- Amish handcrafted to order
- Wooden deep scooped seat
- Floor glides under feet
- Reinforced attachments
- Catalyzed conversion varnish
- Custom hardwood & finish
Price: $413
Pulling in elements of Mid-Century design into a wholly modern aesthetic, the Reyno Side Chair can be customized to include or exclude a seat cushion crafted from your choice of fabric or leather. While sleek and minimalist in its appearance, the Reyno Side Chair provides uncompromising sturdiness and support so diners sit comfortably meal after meal.
Key Features
- Solid hardwood construction
- Amish handcrafted to order
- Wood, fabric, or leather seat
- Floor glides under feet
- Reinforced attachments
- Catalyzed conversion varnish
- Custom hardwood & finish
Price: $358
It’s easy to guess how the Alfred Fiddle Back Dining Chairs earned its name. The wood-crafted motif resembling a fiddle makes the chair feel simultaneously traditional and unique, further enhanced by the shapely turned legs and posts. Beyond the wood species and colors, customizations include whether to include or exclude side-arms and cushions.
Key Features
- Solid hardwood construction
- Optional fabric & leather
- Reinforced attachments
- Turned spindle legs
- Custom hardwood & finish
- Amish handmade in the USA
- Catalyzed conversion varnish
Price: $358
Reclaimed barnwood, true to its name, is carefully sourced by the Amish from old farms and rural structures. Our skilled woodworkers refine each piece, smoothing out rough textures and splinters while preserving the wood’s rich history and natural grain. The result is a chair that’s both exceptionally sturdy and filled with rustic personality. Customize the Elaine Reclaimed Dining Chair by choosing the stains and whether to add arms and cushioning.
Key Features
- Reclaimed hardwood construction
- Side or arm chair available
- Wood, fabric, or leather seat
- Low sheen catalyzed conversion varnish
- Hand-applied finish options
- Amish handmade in the USA
Price: $558
This customizable chair combines classic woodworking with Mid-Century sensibilities and modern minimalism for a piece that can work well in almost any home. Thoughtfully curved to complement your body, the chair reflects top Amish woodworking skills, from the shaping of the legs to the best-in-class joinery.
Key Features
- Solid hardwood construction
- Scooped wooden seat
- Reinforced attachments
- Custom hardwood & finish
- Catalyzed conversion varnish
- Amish handmade in the USA
Price: $313
Customizable Non-upholstered Dining Chairs
Order Customizable Dining Chairs From Countryside Amish Furniture
If you think about it, people ask a lot of their dining chairs—-they support our weight three or more times a day during mealtimes and are repeatedly scooted in-and-out of the table. Moreover, much of the dining room’s decor rests on their design. In this spirit, trust only expert craftspeople to customize chairs on your behalf.
Countryside Amish Furniture offers made-to-order chairs made exclusively by skilled Amish artisans. Prioritizing quality over speed, they produce chairs that are as sturdy as they are beautiful.
Ready to order customizable dining chairs? Browse the hundreds of designs on our site to begin the process!

